Skip to content
Shorts 4 min read

How to Make a Would You Rather Video for Shorts and TikTok

Make Would You Rather videos with two choices, a 5 second timer and the votes revealed. Free in the browser, plus tips for questions that get comments.

Edit online

Make it in your browser, free

Type your text, download the video. No app needed.

On this page · 5 sections
  1. 1. The Would You Rather template
  2. 2. Make it step by step
  3. 3. Write questions people want to answer
  4. 4. Put it together
  5. 5. Checklist

Would You Rather videos ask viewers to choose between two options: "Would you rather be able to fly or be invisible?" They work because everyone has an opinion, so people stop scrolling, pick a side and comment why. A countdown gives them a moment to choose, then the votes show what everyone else picked. On Velosofy you make each question in the browser, ready to post as a Short, a TikTok or a Reel, or as part of a longer YouTube video. This guide shows how to make them, how to write questions that get comments, and how to turn them into a series.

The Would You Rather template

The Would You Rather template shows your heading, two big cards in red and blue and a white OR badge between them. A 5 second timer runs around the badge, then the cards fill up with the votes, the percentages count up and the winning side gets a crown. You type:

Free template

Would You Rather

  • Heading: "Would you rather..." or your own, up to 28 characters
  • Option 1 and Option 2: up to 60 characters each
  • Votes for 1: the percentage for the first choice, the second gets the rest

On vertical and square videos the cards stack on top of each other, on landscape they sit side by side. Each question runs for 10 seconds, with ticks, a beep and a ding for the winner.

Other quiz formats to mix in

FormatTry
Pick one of two, with votesWould You Rather
Fact or fakeTrue Or False Quiz
Results of a poll with more optionsPoll Results Bars
Trivia with four answersFour Answer Quiz Game

Make it step by step

  1. Open the Would You Rather template and go to the editor on its page.
  2. Type both choices. Keep them about the same length, so neither looks more important.
  3. Set the votes with the slider, for example 64% for the first choice.
  4. Pick a font and the animation speed. A faster speed makes a shorter video.
  5. Choose 9:16 for Shorts and TikTok, or 16:9 for YouTube.
  6. Create the video. It renders on our server in about a minute, then you download it.

For the next question, open your video in My videos and make it again. The font, speed and size are kept, so you only change the two choices and the votes.

Write questions people want to answer

Make both sides tempting

"Would you rather have a million euros or a cold?" has an easy answer, so nobody comments. "Would you rather never use your phone again or never watch TV again?" splits people, and that's what gets comments.

Pick a theme

Food, superpowers, school, gaming, travel or "impossible choices": a theme makes a series easier to find and makes people watch the next one. Put it in your title, for example "Would You Rather: Gaming Edition #3".

Use real votes

Ask your followers first with a poll in your YouTube community tab or Instagram story, and use the results in the video. Viewers like to see if they agree with everyone else.

Ask for the comment

End with "Comment your answer" or "Which did you pick?" on screen or in your voice. The Comment Below Prompt does this with an animated arrow.

Put it together

  1. For a Short: one question, a background (a color, gameplay or your own face) and trending music under it, quieter than the ticks.
  2. For a long video: 10 to 20 questions after each other, with an intro and an end screen. See how to make a trivia quiz game video for planning a full quiz.
  3. In CapCut, use the -greenscreen.mp4 as an overlay with Chroma key, see green screen overlays in CapCut. In Premiere Pro, DaVinci Resolve and Final Cut Pro, use the transparent -alpha.mov.

Checklist

  • Two choices that split people, about the same length
  • Votes from a real poll, or numbers that start a discussion
  • A theme and a number in the title
  • "Comment your answer" at the end
  • 9:16 for Shorts and TikTok, 16:9 for a full video

Browse all Shorts templates, read how to make a quiz video for Shorts, or search for quiz templates.

Frequently asked questions

Open the Would You Rather template on Edit online, type your two choices, set how many votes the first one gets and download it with a free account. Make one video per question and put them after each other in your editor.

Each question is 10 seconds: the choices fly in, a 5 second timer runs around the OR badge, then the votes fill up and the winner gets a crown.

You set them yourself with the "Votes for 1" slider, the second choice gets the rest. Use the results of a poll in your community tab or on Instagram stories, or pick numbers that make people comment.

Yes. Change the heading to "This or that?" or "Pick one", and type short choices such as "Pizza" and "Burger". The heading takes up to 28 characters and each choice up to 60.

9:16 vertical for Shorts, TikTok and Reels, where the choices stack on top of each other. 16:9 landscape for a long YouTube video, with the choices side by side. There is also a 1:1 square size.

Edit online

Make your first question

Free with a free account, in 16:9, 9:16 or 1:1.

Type two choices, set the votes and download it with a timer, sound and the winner crowned.

Edit online for free

More articles. Keep learning.

Shorts 6 min read 3 to edit online

How to Make a New Year Countdown Video (2027)

Make a 10 second New Year countdown with fireworks and your own greeting, time it so zero lands on midnight, and use it in Premiere, CapCut or OBS.

Shorts 7 min read 3 to edit online

How to Make Podcast Clips for Shorts, Reels and TikTok

Turn a long podcast into vertical clips: pick a 20-60 second moment, reframe 16:9 to 9:16, add a hook title, big captions, a name tag and a follow card.

Shorts 6 min read 3 to edit online

How to Make a Trivia Quiz Game Video for YouTube (10 to 20 Questions)

Make a full trivia quiz video for YouTube: plan 10 to 20 questions, make each one with a countdown and answer reveal, and put them together.